Unsurprisingly, some folks on raddle and reddit seem to have a big problem with lemmy. A lot of it is pure FUD.

However, this appears to be a valid security concern:

https://raddle.me/f/fediverse/166674/lemmy-is-so-much-like-email-it-even-brought-back-spy-tracker

Any thoughts on how fixable this is?

Of course the general consensus on reddit is “lemmy devs are clueless and dangerous”. I’m pretty sure a lot of it is one guy with multiple alt accounts, tho. He has a Joe McCarthy attitude about lemmy because of one of the primary devs.

  • TheCraiggers@lemmy.worldEnglish
    1·
    1 year ago

    I’m confused. How is this any different getting simply hosting a picture yourself and tracking all the IP addresses via http fetch logs? Why is Lemmy itself being singled out here? Why do you need some CGI script?

    • Boozilla@lemmy.oneOPEnglish
      1·
      1 year ago

      I am not a cybersecurity expert. And these are good questions. The problem is certainly not unique to Lemmy.

      However, my (limited) understanding of it the opposing opinion is. 1. This is bad for privacy (marketers and other bad actors use these to track down your IP and other metadata) and 2. It should have been thought of before now and already had some protections put into place.

      • Teppic@kbin.social
        2·
        1 year ago

        It is being discussed - here is a thread from yesterday:
        https://kbin.social/m/support@lemmy.world/t/204434/Tracking-Lemmy-users-by-spy-tracker-pixels

        And here is an ongoing discussion about a possible remedy:
        https://github.com/LemmyNet/lemmy/pull/3550

        But worth noting, unlike email the ‘view’ isn’t linked to an individual and an email address, and also broadcasting your IP address (yes and some meta data) as you browse isn’t unusual. Every page you visit could be doing this not just Lemmy.
        Yes ideally this should be fixed, but in my view it is also a bit of a storm in a teacup.