• khepri@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    13
    ·
    edit-2
    1 year ago

    I agree that self harm is a tragic response to the kind of environment she was apparently in. I do not agree that this act somehow makes her “perception of the world” (whatever that very broad phrase might mean) unreasonable, or that it proves she has an “extreme personality” (again not sure what, definitionally, that is). I think perfectly normal people react in unexpected ways to extreme environments and unless you have some reason to assume otherwise I’m not sure it’s reasonable to look at self harm and then default to questioning the person first and not the situation first.

    Because you seem very close to implying (and I’m sure this isn’t the case) that issues of “recall” “perception” “reasonableness” and “personality” makes the statements of someone who self-harms untrustworthy, suspicious, or in some way self-serving or discountable. Not saying you were consciously trying to imply that, but that’s probably the cause of the downvotes.