Chana [none/use name]

  • 0 Posts
  • 1.21K Comments
Joined 7 个月前
cake
Cake day: 2025年5月17日

help-circle


  • So is the assumption I was responding to, which assumed that there were trees there to cut down in the first place.

    Both the comment you responded to and the comment you made had that kind of assumption. And I’m not replying to what they said…

    I wasn’t making any normative claims about what the land should be, just pointing out that this process appears to have been afforestation of an area that, prior to this intervention, was grassland, and so the implicit assumption in the original comment that the local water cycle had already been perturbed may be wrong.

    I don’t think that’s what you communicated, actually.


  • The point is that this land was not immutably grassland historically, and so the prior point re: its prior state is not inherently valid. The only question is how long it was the case, if that’s what we are meant to care about.

    I haven’t said anything about whether it’s strategically better in this case, that’s just a category error re: your reply. I am highlighting that one should avoid the (often settler naturalistic fallacy mindset) that the right thing is what it “used to be”, where “used to be” tends to be a somewhat mythological description of the place 50 years ago.








  • Working with others in an org doesn’t require being a leader, friend. Organizations need help doing things like scheduling, creating artwork, writing, putting up posters, handing out flyers, etc etc. And when you first join you’ll probably be doing a lot of reading. Just focus on being friendly and liked and you’ll do well. Sticking to principals / handling political issues is something you can develop later and strategically, if you’d like to, and this ends up being what leadership does.

    One low-stakes thing anyone can do is join a group like Food Not Bombs. They feed people and their members come from a broad left background. I wouldn’t expect to get a good political education there, but you will get comfortable with basic organized left group work! And meet people who will let you know about other local orgs.


  • It is the evil empire, the primary seat of global capital - and capitalism itself is the primary driving force behind all of this. The CIA had no reason to exist outside of the Cold War, and the Cold War was created to contain socialism.

    We’ve got to rely on each other, friend, and organize. It is tempting to prepare as individuals, and it is not bad to do so per se, but it is much less effective than working together in an organization.