• 1.34K Posts
  • 18.5K Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 27th, 2023

help-circle










  • Currently- Richard Roeper (Chicago Sun-Times), Justin Chang (L.A. Times) and J. Hoberman (Village Voice), although admittedly these days since I just sail the high seas most of the time, I often just go by the description and turn it off if I don’t like what I’m watching.

    I used to know older critics better though. I was usually able to figure out whether or not a movie was worth watching by paying attention to Roger Ebert, Leonard Maltin and Pauline Kael (if she liked it, I probably wouldn’t).








  • IMD ratings are stupid. I almost never see a rating even as high as 9 for anything no matter how much people love a movie or consider it one of the greatest ever made:

    Citizen Kane: 8.3
    The Maltese Falcon: 7.9
    Star Wars: 8.6
    No Country for Old Men: 8.2
    The Shining: 8.4
    Lawrence of Arabia: 8.3
    Psycho: 8.5

    Here’s a few 9s.

    Schindler’s List: 9.0
    The Godfather: 9.2
    The Shawshank Redemption: 9.3

    That’s how rare it is. Even The Shawshank Redemption couldn’t get a 10.

    Edit: Whooosh for me on the joke. And I love This is Spinal Tap too. I love it so much I sat through the terrible 4-hour rough cut on the Internet Archive.