• 43 Posts
  • 1.87K Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: January 15th, 2024

help-circle











  • Prunebutt@slrpnk.nettoPalestine@lemmy.mlMr Netanhoo
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    edit-2
    3 days ago

    No where here did we make it facist saying “you did not come from here, get out.” That is not our argument.

    I disagree. I think that’s a core assumend premise of the video. Otherwise, the statement that Bibi’s from Poland doesn’t make any coherent sense as an argument.

    I disagree with the complete “blood and soil” premise that zionism is based on. But I critisize bs logic, no matter which camp it stated.







  • So you’re saying that if a culture has been in a land for a long time, that’s okay?

    Then what’s ok? Genuine question. I don’t follow.

    Indigenous Australians have been on this land for 60,000 years, they have one of the oldest extant cultures on earth. I personally think they get to say “this land is ours”.

    I agree. I also agree that Palestine belongs to the palestinians. But there’s a diffenence between stating that a people has inhabited a land for a long time, resulting in a claim for the land and claiming that some individual person doesn’t belong here, because their family is from someplace else.

    Also, you shouldn’t use Israel’s line of reasoning. Let me give you an example of what I mean:

    Let’s say you wanted to debunk a real NSDAP Nazi from 1940s Germany. Would you agree with them that different races are stronger than the others and that the strongest must dominate the latter, pointing the out that Germany will lose the war, therefore the German “race” can’t be superior… or will you not give credit to that whole premise outright?



  • Do you feel the same about First Nations rights?

    Yes. All the racism BS vanishes if you argue with culture instead of genetics.

    One of the big false claims is that Palestinians are solely from the Arabian peninsula when that’s just unequivocally false. They’re indigenous to the Levant and it’s an important distinction to fight Zionist propoganda. Palestinians have the right to argue against being ethnically cleansed by stating their multigenerational ties to their home. Just like any First Nations people or other nationality.

    I agree. Still not a genetic argument.

    You’re concerned about weaponization of ethnonationalist rhetoric in a context where the power dynamics simply do not support such a concept.

    Can you explain that to me? I don’t follow.