• 0 Posts
  • 125 Comments
Joined 1 year ago
cake
Cake day: June 13th, 2023

help-circle











  • It is not very reliable to use a component to build a model that has “no support from observations”.

    But it has support from observations? It’s an alternative explanation for the red shifts we observe from far away sources.

    ΛCDM has also problems. For example that two different methods of calculating the Hubble constant do not agree, or that the James Webb telescope found galaxies, that are too old. The latter was the motivation for the paper and gives an explanation for it, contrary to current models.

    Yeah, it is not generally a good idea to just throw in more components, like here a scalar.

    Well, guess what the Λ in ΛCDM is? They just put it in there to be able to fit the theory to the observation. And it’s absurd to say, that they would’ve found that in the LHC, when they also did not find dark matter particles, even though they are actively looking for those.

    Does it still explain galaxy rotations? What about other cosmological data, like equation of state parameter and such?

    They are aware of this and mention it already in the abstract:

    It remains to be seen if the new model is consistent with the CMB power spectrum, the Big Bang nucleosynthesis of light elements, and other critical observations.

    It’s quite common for research groups to do this, because their work is quite complex and takes time. They proved that their approach might have some merit and now other groups can help them going forward with it.




  • But that’s not, what they were asked. They were asked about their perception of bullying, so also bullying of others, not only of themselves. I agree, that it would be much better evidence, if they would have just asked if the students get bullied.
    My problem with the perception thing is that everyone tells you, that school uniforms help against bullying and then you get school uniforms. So now you might feel, that there’s less bullying, because you have this foregone conclusion, that it must work.