In an essay on the current justification for authorities in the EU and around the globe seeking to break end-to-end-encryption to fight child sexual abuse and exploitation, researcher Susan Landau discusses the issue in historical context, and explains why breaking encryption leads us in the wrong direction.
“Think differently. Think long term. Think about protecting the privacy and security of all members of society—children and adults alike. By failing to consider the big picture, the U.K. Online Safety Act has taken a dangerous, short-term approach to a complex societal problem. The EU and U.S. have the chance to avoid the U.K.’s folly; they should do so. The EU proposal and the U.S. bills are not sensible ways to approach the public policy concerns of online abetting of CSAE [Child Sexual Abuse and Exploitation]. Nor are these reasonable approaches in view of the cyber threats our society faces. The bills should be abandoned, and we should pursue other ways of protecting both children and adults.”
[Edit typo.]
Pointing out opinions, and flaws of a plan according to opinions is useful. And it’s a good exercise. But it’s not science.
Getting access to the world’s data, isn’t about protecting anybody, it’s about getting access to the data, the excuses just an excuse. But that’s just my opinion.
And getting access to all that data is dangerous and will lead to abuses
And instead of making us safer from crime it will make us less safe from crime
https://cyberhoot.com/blog/fake-emergency-search-warrants-becoming-a-problem/
https://krebsonsecurity.com/2022/03/fake-emergency-search-warrants-draw-scrutiny-from-capitol-hill/
The science of information theory has pointed out what properties are possible and not possible from these systems. From there, areas like sociology has pointed out the social consequences. And those consequences are bad according to the vast majority of people.
The only opinion here is if it’s good or bad to increase risks of harm (and what counts as harm, but that’s not the issue at hand). And I say that’s bad.